Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links. If you choose to make a purchase through one of these links, I’ll receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support my work and allows me to provide affordable dog training services to those in need.

Want to contribute directly? You can always buy me a coffee on Ko-fi: https://ko-fi.com/painteddogtrainingco

As a dog trainer, I often find myself repeating a key piece of advice: if your pup is misbehaving, don’t just tell them what not to do, teach them an incompatible behavior. This simple yet powerful shift in our approach can transform the dog training experience and yield exceptional results.

Understanding Incompatible Behaviors

Let’s unpack what “incompatible behaviors” actually means. An incompatible behavior is an action your dog cannot perform at the same time as the unwanted behavior. Some classic examples include:

• A dog cannot jump up excitedly and sit politely at the same time.
• A dog cannot bark relentlessly and focus their attention on a fetch toy or engage in a game of tug.
• A dog cannot lunge on the leash and focus on you.

The beauty of focusing on incompatible behaviors is that we are essentially guiding our dogs towards positive, desirable actions rather than merely suppressing the undesired ones. The dog is much more likely to stop unwanted behavior if it knows what positive behavior it should be doing.

The Problem with Suppression

When we only reprimand a dog for doing something we don’t like (saying “no,” making a corrective sound, or even using mild physical punishment), we haven’t actually taught the dog an alternative behavior. This leaves a void. It might temporarily suppress the unwanted action out of fear or confusion, but it doesn’t give the dog a clear picture of what we want them to do.

This suppression-only approach can lead to several issues:

• Confusion and Frustration: Your dog simply knows they’re doing something “wrong,” but they have no idea what would be “right.”
• Resurgence of Unwanted Behavior: Since a new skill hasn’t been learned, the old unwanted behavior is likely to come creeping back.
• Negative Associations: If your dog repeatedly associates interactions with you as full of corrections, it can damage your bond.

The Benefits of Teaching Incompatible Behaviors

By teaching incompatible behaviors, we transform the training dynamic in several exciting ways:

• Clarity and Empowerment: You provide your dog with a constructive outlet and clear direction on what you’d like them to do. This allows them to take charge and act with confidence.
• Proactive Problem Solving: Instead of playing a game of “whack-a-mole” with recurring behavioral issues, you equip your dog with the tools to avoid them.
• Positive Reinforcement: This approach leans heavily on positive reinforcement, rewarding your dog for the incompatible behavior. This builds enthusiasm and strengthens your relationship. The incompatible behavior MUST be more rewarding than the unwanted one.
• Sustainable Results: Since your dog actually learns a desirable skill, they’re far less likely to revert to unwanted behaviors.

How to Implement Incompatible Behaviors

Here’s the basic process for utilizing incompatible behaviors in your training:

1. Identify the Problem Behavior: Clearly define what your dog is doing that you want to change (e.g., jumping up on guests).
2. Choose a Suitable Incompatible Behavior: Think of a behavior that makes it physically impossible to do the unwanted behavior (e.g., teaching a reliable “sit” or “place” for when guests arrive ).
3. Train the New Skill: Dedicate time to teaching your dog the new, incompatible behavior in low stakes environments at first and reward them heavily for it.
4. Management and Practice: In the early stages, manage the environment to minimize opportunities for the unwanted behavior while you strengthen the new skill through practice.
5. Reward, Reward, Reward!: When your dog chooses the incompatible behavior in a tempting situation, make sure to shower them with praise and desirable rewards.

The Power of Saying “Yes!”

Teaching your dog incompatible behaviors allows you to focus on saying “Yes!” rather than constantly saying “No!”. This shift builds a positive and proactive relationship with your dog, making training sessions enjoyable and fostering the desire to learn more. If you’re saying “no” half as much as you’re saying “yes!”, it means you’re doing something wrong.

Remember, patience and consistency are crucial. With dedication to teaching incompatible behaviors, you pave the way for a well mannered, happy dog who shines in any situation.